(Black and) Blue and White

by | Blog, March / April 2020

By Cliff Keller — We have been misinformed. Recent events suggest that the world’s oldest pastime, if not profession, contrary to longstanding claims to the contrary, must surely be criticism. Criticism’s probable precedence over all other human pursuits makes perfect sense. Passing judgment is fun, easy to do, has no age limitations and requires neither logic, training or education to participate.

Take recent response to British Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s revelation that he has tested positive for COVID-19. (There exists an unwritten but obvious rule that, until further notice, all idle thoughts, learned papers, conversations and, of course, blog entries must at least mention the Coronavirus. I’m only doing my part.)

“Mr. Johnson’s handling of the crisis has borne an unsettling resemblance to that of President Trump,” recently wrote The New York Times’ Michelle Cottle (obeying another unwritten rule by scratching at the Times’ favorite president while taking a shot at Johnson). “[Johnson] was slow to recognize the risks, taking a mid-February holiday with his pregnant fiancée at his country home. Even after the virus became impossible to ignore, he remained glib and dismissive, as his government dithered and failed to put together a coherent response.”

Glibness. Dithering. Incoherency. Going on holiday! Outrageous. By her insightful remarks, Ms. Cottle has surely made this troubled world a better place.

In the same spirit, a British critic recently pronounced Johnson unqualified to lead England’s fight against Corona because he had contracted the disease himself, which seems much like claiming that a colorblind man could not possibly paint a house.

“It behooves every man to remember that the work of the critic is of altogether secondary importance,” said former American president Theodore Roosevelt, “and that, in the end, progress is accomplished by the man who does things.”

But the thing modern politicians, media personalities and pundits seem to accomplish most often, is to criticize their opponents, often viciously, irresponsibly and selfishly. There may be no better example of this amplified modern practice than in Israel, where a cycle of politically motivated legal maneuvers and personal attacks against Benjamin Netanyahu and his family forced three inconclusive elections. But the threat of a fourth election may have been averted by a surprising, eleventh hour and perhaps noble compromise made at enormous political cost by, in some eyes, the nation’s leading villain, the Blue and White party’s Benny Gantz.

Though Blue and White had proved to be just popular enough to produce a political stalemate here in Israel, its formation from three, smaller Israeli political parties seems to have been more motivated by a shared loathing of Netanyahu than common ideals.

By agreeing to join a unity government with Netanyahu and break Israel’s electoral stalemate, Gantz stunned his Blue and White allies and may have also saved, for the moment, representative governance in Israel. Rather than receiving praise for agreeing to compromise, Gantz took immediate abuse.

“Yair Lapid and Moshe Ya’alon, leaders of the Yesh Atid and Telem factions in Blue and White, slammed Benny Gantz’s decision to enter a government with longtime foe Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Thursday night,” reported The Times of Israel, “saying the Blue and White leader had abandoned his principles by ‘crawling’ into a coalition of ‘extremists and extortionists.’

“Lapid said Gantz had betrayed Blue and White’s voters, stolen their votes and handed them to Netanyahu. Despite his claims, Gantz was not entering a unity government, but had simply ‘surrendered’ to Netanyahu, Lapid charged.”

Remember, Israel has no constitution. Some here had feared that, if we failed to select a government at the polls, the Israeli supreme court or, as unthinkable as it may seem, perhaps even the military might have stepped in and attempted to dictate Israel’s future.

I was no fan of candidate Gantz but his recent enabling gesture seems to have served Israel a powerful mitzvah.

*****
SUBSCRIBE to continue reading this article and access more content about Israel and the Messianic Community around the world.

The Ongoing Battle for Yom Ha’atzmaut – Israel’s Independence Day

Yom Ha'atzmaut, Israel's Independence Day, holds a profound significance not only for Israelis, but for the global Jewish community and all those who value freedom and self-determination. This day commemorates the historic declaration of independence of the State of...

Behind the Curtain: The Candles Burn What Really Happened in the Jewish Community of Belarus

As assaults against the Jewish people continue to shake the Jewish world, Reach Initiative International, a ministry founded many years ago by Rabbi Stewart and Chantal Winograd, seems to always appear at the center of the conflict, whether it’s in Israel, the...

Beth Shechinah Celebrates Thirty Years of Glorifying G-d

This is an exciting year for Rabbi Calev (Cal) Goldberg and Congregation Beth Shechinah in Calgary, Canada. The congregation celebrated its 30-year anniversary after Passover this year. In celebration of this amazing milestone, they showed a video of the past years...

The Rich Heritage of Persian Jews and the Festival of Purim

The Persian Jews hold a most special claim to the festival of Purim. The story of Mordechai, Queen Esther, ‘Setara’ in Persian, and the Jewish people in their fight against the evil Haman, took place in Babylon. This became the great Persian Empire and eventually...

IDF Sergeant Major Chaim Malespin: A Life of Service to G-d

Israeli Messianic Believer Chaim Malespin is not only the co-founder of the Aliyah Return Center, an Israel based non-profit organization that assists new Jewish immigrants, but is also a sergeant major in the IDF (Israel Defense Forces) Combat Engineering Corp’s...

Are the Jewish People REALLY Indigenous to the Land of Israel?

While the Jewish community in Israel, and across the Diaspora, are preparing and enjoying yet another year of commemorating the Passover, there are a growing number of people in the world who are falling into the same trap of the “holocaust deniers”. In this case,...

A Messianic View on the Israel-Hamas War

On that horrific Shabbat day of October 7th, Simcha Torah, a holiday of joy and celebration on the Jewish calendar, violence struck the Jewish people in Israel with a massacre of biblical proportions. Yes, there have been many wars in Israel but the onslaught was so...

Israel Experiences National Unity and Spiritual Revival During the War

It was the summer of 2023 that the words ’Civil War’ loomed at the forefront of almost every Israeli conversation. The country of Israel was, indeed, broken and ripped in pieces politically—left versus right. Judicial reform was promised by the right-wing government...

Antisemitism: History’s Oldest Hatred

The horrific events of October 7, 2023, now known as Black Saturday, were tragic. However, one only needs to tune into the local news for a moment to realize the massacre of Black Saturday has somehow triggered an open season on Jewish people around the world. But...

A Biblical View of Messiah’s Miraculous Birth

The Tanakh, also known as the Old Testament, prophecies of a Messiah who will come to usher in an era when the people of the world will live together in harmony and righteousness. The term Messiah (Mashiach in Hebrew) means “anointed one.” From the beginning, the...